Cards under $200 – Page 12 – Western NY Sports Cards

Switch to our Consignment Marketplace

Our Buy/Sell/Trade Discord is Now Live! >>

Mike Trout - 2025 Topps Series 1 - Game Day Drip - Angels

Mike Trout - 2025 Topps Series 1 - Game Day Drip - Angels

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Royce Lewis - 2025 Topps Series 2 - 1990 Insert - Twins

Royce Lewis - 2025 Topps Series 2 - 1990 Insert - Twins

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Mike Yastrzemski - 2025 Topps Series 2 - 1990 Insert - Giants

Mike Yastrzemski - 2025 Topps Series 2 - 1990 Insert - Giants

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Jordan Westburg - 2024 Topps Series 1 - Rookie base card - Orioles

Jordan Westburg - 2024 Topps Series 1 - Rookie base card - Orioles

Regular price $0.86

Regular price Sale price $0.86
Unit price per
Nolan Schanuel - 2024 Topps Series 1 - Rookie base card - Angels

Nolan Schanuel - 2024 Topps Series 1 - Rookie base card - Angels

Regular price $0.86

Regular price Sale price $0.86
Unit price per
Brooks Lee - 2025 Bowman - Rockstar Rookies - Twins

Brooks Lee - 2025 Bowman - Rockstar Rookies - Twins

Regular price $1.99

Regular price Sale price $1.99
Unit price per
Coby Mayo - 2025 Bowman - Rookie of the Year Favorites - Orioles

Coby Mayo - 2025 Bowman - Rookie of the Year Favorites - Orioles

Regular price $1.99

Regular price Sale price $1.99
Unit price per
Aidan Miller - 2024 Bowman - 1st Paper prospect - Phillies

Aidan Miller - 2024 Bowman - 1st Paper prospect - Phillies

Regular price $1.49

Regular price Sale price $1.49
Unit price per
Spencer Jones - 2024 Bowman - Paper prospect - Yankees

Spencer Jones - 2024 Bowman - Paper prospect - Yankees

Regular price $0.86

Regular price Sale price $0.86
Unit price per
Adrian Beltre - 2025 Topps Series 1 - 1990 Insert - Rangers

Adrian Beltre - 2025 Topps Series 1 - 1990 Insert - Rangers

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Carlton Fisk - 2022 Topps Heritage High Number - 1973 MLB All-Star Game Highlights - Red Sox

Carlton Fisk - 2022 Topps Heritage High Number - 1973 MLB All-Star Game Highlights - Red Sox

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Spencer Strider - 2024 Topps Series 2 - 1989 All-Star Insert - Braves

Spencer Strider - 2024 Topps Series 2 - 1989 All-Star Insert - Braves

Regular price $1.99

Regular price Sale price $1.99
Unit price per
Matt Chapman - 2024 Topps Update - 1989 Insert - Giants

Matt Chapman - 2024 Topps Update - 1989 Insert - Giants

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Anthony Volpe - 2024 Topps Update - 1989 Insert - Yankees

Anthony Volpe - 2024 Topps Update - 1989 Insert - Yankees

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Salvador Perez - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Royals

Salvador Perez - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Royals

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Josh Naylor - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Guardians

Josh Naylor - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Guardians

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Marcus Semien - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Rangers

Marcus Semien - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Rangers

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Jurickson Profar - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Padres

Jurickson Profar - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Padres

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Mason Miller - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Athletics

Mason Miller - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Athletics

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Chris Sale - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Braves

Chris Sale - 2024 Topps Update - All Star Game - Braves

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Julio Rodriguez - 2024 Bowman - Base Paper - Mariners

Julio Rodriguez - 2024 Bowman - Base Paper - Mariners

Regular price $0.75

Regular price Sale price $0.75
Unit price per
Druw Jones - 2024 Bowman - Bowman AI - Diamondbacks

Druw Jones - 2024 Bowman - Bowman AI - Diamondbacks

Regular price $1.99

Regular price Sale price $1.99
Unit price per
Francisco Alvarez - 2023 Topps Heritage - Base Card - Mets

Francisco Alvarez - 2023 Topps Heritage - Base Card - Mets

Regular price $0.75

Regular price Sale price $0.75
Unit price per
Jackson Holliday - 2024 Topps Update - Rookie Debut Base - Orioles

Jackson Holliday - 2024 Topps Update - Rookie Debut Base - Orioles

Regular price $0.86

Regular price Sale price $0.86
Unit price per
Bryce Harper - 2024 Topps Archives - Base - Phillies

Bryce Harper - 2024 Topps Archives - Base - Phillies

Regular price $0.86

Regular price Sale price $0.86
Unit price per
Ken Griffey Jr. - 2024 Topps Archives - Base - Mariners

Ken Griffey Jr. - 2024 Topps Archives - Base - Mariners

Regular price $0.99

Regular price Sale price $0.99
Unit price per
Roki Sasaki - 2025 Topps Archives - Base - Dodgers

Roki Sasaki - 2025 Topps Archives - Base - Dodgers

Regular price $0.86

Regular price Sale price $0.86
Unit price per
Yoshinobu Yamamoto - 2025 Topps Archives - Base - Dodgers

Yoshinobu Yamamoto - 2025 Topps Archives - Base - Dodgers

Regular price $0.86

Regular price Sale price $0.86
Unit price per
Elly De La Cruz / Shohei Ohtani / Brice Turang - 2025 Topps Heritage - Base - Reds

Elly De La Cruz / Shohei Ohtani / Brice Turang - 2025 Topps Heritage - Base - Reds

Regular price $0.99

Regular price Sale price $0.99
Unit price per
Bobby Witt Jr. / Vladimir Guerrero Jr. / Aaron Judge - 2025 Topps Heritage - Base - Royals

Bobby Witt Jr. / Vladimir Guerrero Jr. / Aaron Judge - 2025 Topps Heritage - Base - Royals

Regular price $0.86

Regular price Sale price $0.86
Unit price per
Billy Carlson - 2026 Bowman - Scouts Top 100 Insert - White Sox

Billy Carlson - 2026 Bowman - Scouts Top 100 Insert - White Sox

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Daniel Pierce - 2026 Bowman - Scouts Top 100 Insert - Rays

Daniel Pierce - 2026 Bowman - Scouts Top 100 Insert - Rays

Regular price $1.75

Regular price Sale price $1.75
Unit price per
Connelly Early - 2026 Bowman - Under the Radar Insert - Red Sox

Connelly Early - 2026 Bowman - Under the Radar Insert - Red Sox

Regular price $1.99

Regular price Sale price $1.99
Unit price per
Nick Kurtz - 2026 Bowman - Power Chords Insert - Athletics

Nick Kurtz - 2026 Bowman - Power Chords Insert - Athletics

Regular price $1.99

Regular price Sale price $1.99
Unit price per
Cal Raleigh - 2026 Bowman - Electric Sluggers Insert - Mariners

Cal Raleigh - 2026 Bowman - Electric Sluggers Insert - Mariners

Regular price $1.99

Regular price Sale price $1.99
Unit price per
Tony Gwynn - 2026 Topps Series 2 - Crooked Numbers - Padres

Tony Gwynn - 2026 Topps Series 2 - Crooked Numbers - Padres

Regular price $1.99

Regular price Sale price $1.99
Unit price per

If you experience any difficulty using this website or accessing any content due to a disability, please contact us so we can assist you and improve accessibility for all users.